Nassau County
Administrative Code Section 8-7.0 (g), in effect March 16, 2004,
provides:
Except for a
felony offense, as defined in section eleven hundred ninety-three of the Vehicle
and Traffic Law, which may give rise to a forfeiture action pursuant to article
thirteen-A of the Civil Practice Law and Rules, the County of Nassau may
commence a civil action for forfeiture to such county of any vehicle as such
term is defined in subdivision fourteen of section 10.00 of the Penal Law when
such vehicle is operated by a person charged with a violation of section eleven
hundred ninety-two of the Vehicle and Traffic Law and such person is convicted or
pleads guilty to any subdivision of such section where it is proved by a
preponderance of the evidence in a civil forfeiture proceeding that such person
was driving in violation of such section. Subject to the provisions of
subparagraph f of this paragraph, the interest of a lienholder in such property
shall not be subject to forfeiture pursuant to this paragraph, provided,
however, that this provision shall not be construed to entitle a lienholder to
more than the outstanding balance of the lien. For purposes of this section, the
term "lienholder" shall mean any person, corporation, partnership, firm, agency,
association or other entity who at the time of an arrest pursuant to this
section has a financial interest recorded as a lien with the Department of Motor
Vehicles of New York State or any other state, territory, district, province,
nation or other jurisdiction, except that "lienholder" shall not mean an entity
that leases vehicles pursuant to a written agreement subject to the New York
state personal property law or the uniform commercial code. Nothing in this
provision shall be
construed
to prevent a lienholder whose lien is not so recorded from intervening in any
action or proceeding under this paragraph.
a. A
person from whom a vehicle has been removed and impounded by the police
pursuant to an arrest for a violation of any provision of section eleven hundred
ninety-two of the Vehicle and Traffic Law shall receive notice at the time of
arrest on such charge and by certified mail, return receipt requested,
as soon thereafter as practical informing
such person how and when the vehicle may be reclaimed and that the
vehicle is subject to a civil forfeiture proceeding. In the event that the
driver is not the registered owner of the vehicle ,separate notice shall be
provided to the registered owner of the vehicle. Notice shall also be provided
to any lienholder. A vehicle removed and impounded pursuant to this section
shall be subject to a reasonable fee upon release of the vehicle covering the
cost of removal and storage.
b. In the
event that the driver of the vehicle has a prior conviction, within the past ten
years, for a violation of any provision of section eleven hundred ninety-two of
the Vehicle and Traffic Law or an offense involving the use of alcohol or a
controlled substance while operating a vehicle in another jurisdiction, the
County may retain the vehicle and shall
apply to the court, after having provided notice as required to the
persons or entities set forth in subparagraph a of this paragraph, within
fifteen days for a prompt hearing to request the court to take measures to
protect the public safety and to protect the vehicle from destruction or sale
during the pendency of the forfeiture proceeding. At such hearing the court
shall determine the probable validity of the retention of the vehicle by the
County, or other such appropriate measures, including but not limited to the
installation at the expense of the owner of an interlock device to prevent the
operation of the vehicle while the driver is under the influence of alcohol, the
posting of a bond or an order restraining the sale or transfer of title of the
vehicle. The hearing shall take into consideration, but not be limited
to: (i) the existence of probable cause for
the underlying arrest; (ii) the likelihood of success on the merits of
the forfeiture action; and (iii) the driver's prior conviction, within the past
ten years, for a violation of any provision of section eleven hundred ninety-two
of the Vehicle and Traffic Law or for an offense regarding the use of alcohol or
a controlled substance while operating a
vehicle in another jurisdiction..
c. The owner
of a vehicle subject to forfeiture pursuant to this paragraph must notify the
County of any intention to transfer ownership or possession of such
vehicle, no later than fifteen days prior
to such transfer. Notice provided pursuant to subparagraph a of this
paragraph shall set forth the time and manner and procedures for such
notification to the County. The provisions of this subparagraph shall remain in
effect until the resolution of the forfeiture
proceeding, provided, however, that the
notice requirement herein shall expire one hundred twenty days after an
arrest pursuant to this paragraph in the event the County has not commenced such
a proceeding within such period.
(i) Nothing in
this subparagraph shall be construed to affect the ability of an entity that
leases vehicles or a lienholder to exercise its lawful rights
to obtain possession of a vehicle under a
contract or applicable law. (ii) In the event of a transfer of title or
possession pursuant to clause (i)
of
this subparagraph, the person or entity that affects such transfer shall provide
notice to the County of its action as soon as practicable and in no event later
than seventy-two hours subsequent to such action.
d. Upon
receiving notification pursuant to subparagraph c of this paragraph, the County
may apply for a court order to ensure that the vehicle remain available
pending the outcome of the civil forfeiture
proceeding pursuant to this paragraph. At such hearing the County may
request appropriate measures including, but not limited to, an order of the
court restraining the transfer of title or possession of such vehicle, retention
by the County of the vehicle pending the outcome of the forfeiture proceeding,
or a bond in the amount of fifteen hundred
dollars plus the fair market value of the vehicle at the time of the arrest, as
set forth in subparagraph e of this paragraph.
e. A person
who transfers title or possession of a vehicle without providing notice to the
County as required by subparagraph c of this paragraph shall be subject, upon a
judgment that the vehicle shall be forfeited, to a penalty in the amount of
fifteen hundred dollars in addition to the fair market value of the vehicle at
the time of the arrest. Evidence of such fair market value may be established
with reference to publications such as, but not limited to, Kelley
Blue Book or NADA guide.
f. It shall be
an affirmative defense to an action brought pursuant to this paragraph that the
owner of the vehicle other than the person arrested for violation of any
provision of section eleven hundred ninety-two of the Vehicle and Traffic Law
did not know, or had no reason to know, that there was a reasonable likelihood
that the vehicle would be used in violation of any such provision.
g. Following a
determination by the court pursuant to this paragraph that a vehicle shall be
forfeited, an owner may petition the court for relief from such determination.
Such petition shall contain an affirmation that the loss of the vehicle would
cause a substantial and unwarranted hardship because the owner has no reasonable
access to public transportation or to the use of another vehicle and lacks the
financial resources to purchase another vehicle
and that possession of a vehicle is a
necessary incident to his or her employment, business, trade, occupation or
profession; or to his or her travel to and from a class or course at an
accredited school, college or university or at a state approved institution of
vocational or technical training; or necessary travel to and from a necessary
medical examination or necessary medical treatment for such owner or a member of
his or her household. Upon demonstration of these factors satisfactory to the
court, the court may grant relief from the forfeiture determination upon such
terms and conditions as will provide
maximum protection to the public safety.
h. Notice
pursuant to this paragraph shall be to the address recorded with the
Department of Motor Vehicles by certified
mail, return receipt requested.
(Amended
by Local Law No. 4-2003, in effect March 10, 2003; REPEALED and re-enacted by
Local Law No. 5-2004, in effect March 16, 2004.)